I picked up this book because a lot of my friends claim this book and the related ministries as an influence on them. My only exposure to Mark Dever before reading this book was Q and A sessions I watched on YouTube from GTY, Ligonier etc. I wanted to better understand the Reformed Baptist churches especially in the Indian context. The edition I read came out in 2004. I don’t know how much the book has changed in the last 22 years.
Dr. Dever lays out his thesis very plainly in the Introduction, stating that he is not writing about the marks of living churches as opposed to dead churches but about the marks of healthy churches as opposed to unhealthy ones. I think the book may be considered an attempt to further the two Reformational marks of a true church (ie. preaching of the word and the administration of the sacraments) into all corners with the view to pressing on churches to maturity. I would think that the first five marks (expository preaching, biblical theology, the Gospel, theology of conversion, theology of evangelism) can be considered healthy fruit on the tree of ‘preaching the word.’ The last four marks (theology of church membership, church discipline, concern for growth, and church leadership) may be considered healthy fruits growing on the ‘administer the sacraments’ tree. Admittedly, this is stretching the categories a bit too thin but I think it works as an overall schema.
There was much that I appreciated in the book. The emphasis on expository preaching and biblical theology and the laying of the Gospel of God’s grace in detail. Truly, God wants His churches to receive the whole counsel of God from Genesis to Revelation in all its width and depth, with Christ Jesus’ saving work in His death and resurrection at the centre of it. Truly, we contribute nothing to our salvation except the sin that makes it necessary. I appreciated the orientation of this book, which was to equip churches to produce future church ministers from the congregation itself. He acutely hits all the major maladies plaguing the broader evangelical church. He touched at nerve by highlighting the pragmatic, managerial, salesman-type approach that has unfortunately come to characterize much of evangelicalism in the past 150 years. In its place he insisted fidelity what Scripture teaches concerning how God saves sinners. All healthy Christians should be able to articulate the Gospel in one minute or less. I don’t think by this he meant with all the sophistication you would expect from a seminary student.
I began to disagree with some stuff starting with his chapter on evangelism. I think most of my disagreements with him were paradigmatic—approaching things from a Reformed Presbyterian versus a Reformed Baptist perspective. But this one perhaps is not. I do not think everyone in the church should evangelise. It would be great if everyone did but I do not think everyone’s gifting lies in this area. I do believe that all Christians are called to be a witness to Christ through their actions and their words. For example, a Christian may witness to his faith by not going along with non-Christians in some of their celebrations which have excess partying. Or a Christian may stand up against a sin in his extended family and refuse to go along with the ways of the world manifest in his extended family. But not everyone is able to articulate the faith as clearly as Dr. Dever suggests that they should. I think every Christian should be able to say, “I belong to Jesus and you can too,” or “If you trust in Jesus, your sins will be forgiven,” but I wouldn’t lay the burden of evangelizing proper on every Christian. I think it is beneficial for a young man to do it once. It’s a humbling experience and good for your soul. I doubt if Dr. Dever is trying to lay a burden on his readers to evangelize but it does seem like he pushes for the urgency with which everyone needs to be doing it right now.
The urgency bit, in my opinion, may reflect a certain eschatological pessimism. I do agree that we must urge people to repent of their sins because we do not know when they might die. Death can come to any of us anytime and in that sense, we must be urgent in calling sinners to repentance. Yet, we must not let this urgency overpower us lest we be discouraged at the state of the earth. The Lord is patient with the sinner and so must we be. The doctrine of divine providence teaches us to lay down the Gospel and surrender the person before us into the hands of the Spirit cheerfully. As Dr. Dever himself says, the Gospel will have its effect—from life to life or from death to death.
At many times in the book mention was made about how there is no such thing as a Christian nation. And how if the church tries to fix society, it loses focus on its duty to purify the church. This is a paradigmatic difference arising out of his Baptist tradition and my Presbyterian tradition. In highlighting Baptist individual church membership, he points out how this unique Baptist vantage point of not including children of believers automatically (and perhaps citizens automatically) contributes to America’s view of religious liberty. The church is not for you and your children and every citizen. It is for believers, he says. This is not at all surprising coming from his perspective. What is surprising is Ligon Duncan’s endorsement on the book’s back cover as “a biblical prescription for faithfulness.” Just to be clear, at least on that mark, Presbyterian and all non-Baptist churches would be unhealthy according to Dr. Dever. I cannot see how Rev. Duncan can endorse it as he does.
Another paradigmatic difference was in the chapter on church discipline. While I agreed with the substance of the argument in that chapter—the need for it, the warrant for it, caution in it etc, I do think Pastor Doug Wilson’s analogy of the nightclub tracks here. Presbyterian churches are like nightclubs with minimal security at the door but bouncers in the mix in the club. Baptist churches are like nightclubs with robust security at the door. Reading this book made me realize that Baptists have strong bouncers at the door and in the club.
I greatly benefited from his chapter on discipleship and growth as well as his chapter on biblical leadership. I liked the BOSS acronym for leadership that he has. A church officer must be a boss giving commands in accordance with that Scirpture teaches, out front leading by his example, supplying his congregation with the tools to do the work of ministry and serving their needs in humility and love. I found his observation that all churches are congregationalist striking. He said that all people in churches vote (if not formally then by their money and by their presence/absence at church). That being it, he still insists there are some special things God has called qualified men called elders to do. Moreover, some particularly gifted elders must be teachers and supported by the church. Earlier he tries to refute presbyterianism/episcopalianism by putting distance between the calling of the apostles and today’s church officers but later uses the analogy between the two to establish the office of elder and pastor. I would argue that inasmuch as all churches are congregationalist, they are also functionally presbyterian (what else are pastoral conferences?) and also functionally episcopalian (not in a sectarian sense but some pastors do end up shaping a group of churches in a particular way by being ‘pastors of pastors’). In my experience, functionally churches function somewhere in between the three forms of church government and different temptations attend all three. Managerialism and authoritarianism plagues episcopalianism. Bureaucracy and theological wrangling plagues presbyterianism. Brute democracy and its attendant threats of anarchy and personality-totalitarianism plague congregationalism.
Lastly, I do think the book suffers from being too long. Many sections repeat the same basic concept but that may be owing to Dr. Dever’s desire to drill into our heads the unchangeable truths of the Gospel. All in all, I found the book a refreshing read on the doctrines of grace. It highlighted for me the key differences between the shape of Reformed Baptist and Presbyterian church government which does trickle down into every life and societal vision in manifold ways.
Originally published on The Flying Scroll.




Leave a comment
Please log in to join the conversation — it's free. Don't have an account? Join here.