Introduction
The NT was written in a period of transition and instability. With the benefit of hindsight we now see that the Lord was doing something remarkable during that time which would split history into two through the incarnation of our Lord. But even speaking in human terms, it is manifest that Israel was in a period of great turmoil and change. People were in anticipation of remarkable things to come. This is evidenced by the fact that many leaders lay claim to the title of the coming Messiah in those days. People even wondered if John the Baptist was the Messiah, a fact that he most vehemently denied. The passion of the people was easily roused to rally behind various causes. One word that categorizes the situation within which the NT was being written is zeal. Everyone from the Sadducees and the Pharisees about whom we read in the Gospels to the fringe cult groups of the Essenes and the band of Judas the Galilean were deeply passionate and zealous for the issues that bound them together into factions. Wise Gamaliel encouraged the Sandhedrin not to despise the zeal of the newly anointed Christians for who knows, he said, if in opposing them they might be opposing God? The church today is also in a time of great zeal. Especially after the death of Charlie Kirk, the political right has fragmented into various impassioned groups. It behooves us as Christians to test the spirits and recognize and separate ‘zeal for Your house’ from ‘zeal without knowledge.’
Zealots in OT Times
Ironically, the NT world was also a time of apostasy. Indeed, it is in the context of apostasy that zeal often rises. This was the case with Phineas, the classic exemplar of zeal for God, who understood that God’s judgment was going to fall on the whole house of Israel if the sin of sleeping with foreign women was not brought to an end. The people had fallen for the sin of Baal-Peor and Phinehas caught an Israelite in bed with a Midianite woman. He barged into the tent with a spear and thrust it through both of them in the very act of adultery. The Lord praised his gory act of righteousness saying that he ‘made atonement for the children of Israel.’ (Num 25:13) It was because of Phinehas’ zeal that God had stayed his hand and consumed not the people. He also counted this ‘unto him for righteousness unto all generations forevermore.’ (Psalm 106:31) Elijah also displayed great zeal for the Lord in the context of apostasy. He slew the prophets of Baal when it became manifestly clear that God Jehovah is the true and living God and compared to Him, Baal is as nothing (1 Kings 19:10).
This same zeal characterized Ezra and Nehemiah as they asked the Israelites to put away foreign wives and worked on rebuilding the Temple and the city of Jerusalem. This same zeal carried on into the intertestamental period in the Maccabean revolt as old Mattathias, the Hasmonean patriarch, resisted the encroachment of Greek pagan worship in his small village of Modin. He did this by slaying an Israelite sent by Antiochus IV to sacrifice to Zeus and called upon all faithful Israelites saying, “Let every one who is zealous for the law and supports the covenant come out with me!” (1 Maccabees 2:27) Later on when he lay dying, he commissioned his sons to be zealous too, citing explicitly the examples of the zeal of Phinehas and Elijah respectively (1 Maccabees 2:54, 58). The Hasmonean dynasty was built to be a stronghold of zeal for the law of God in a time of pluralistic compromise. Even so, the corruption in the dynasty, especially the ecclesiocratic subterfuge of the Aaronic priesthood by the presiding ruler, inspired some groups of people to abandon this organized state religion and form a religious community in the desert. Notably, the Essenes viewed themselves as the truly zealous ones unlike the compromised Hasmoneans. It is noteworthy, however, that just like the Hasmoneans, because of their zeal the Essenes capitulated to the evil king Herod simply because he was opposed to the Hasmoneans, their common enemy.1
Zealots in NT times
As evidenced by these two intertestimental examples of zeal for the Lord/His law, zeal did not always translate to righteousness. This admixture of good and evil in zeal continued in the first century AD. While historically ‘zeal for the law’ bore a positive connotation, for Josephus, the Jewish historian, zealotry was largely a negative enterprise. Close to the destruction of the temple in 70AD, the Zealots had come to represent a well defined political faction. Even so, according to Josephus, the roots of this movement lay in the initiatives of one Judas the Galilean beginning in 6AD, who equated paying taxes to the Roman government as unfaithfulness to God and rallied people to refuse to pay any tribute to Caesar.2 According to F F Bruce, there was another Galilean zealot uprising in 4BC under another Judas son of Hezekiah. Bruce suggests that these two Judas’ may be the same person. If this identification is valid, it shows us the ‘hereditary principle’ being ‘perpetuated in the insurgent leadership’ because sons of Judas the Galilean continues zealous uprisings against the Romans until 66AD when one of his descendants Menahem played an energetic role in the Jewish revolt and another relative Eleazar ben Jair ‘held out until the bitter end at Masada’ in 73AD.3 This would line up with the hereditary zeal of the Hasmoneans.
Judas the Galilean’s tribute dispute forms the background of the question posed to Jesus concerning the payment of taxes to Caesar by the Pharisees and the Herodians (Mark 12:14). Judas is also mentioned by Gamaliel in Acts 5:37 where he says that he had risen in the census. This refers to the census of Quirinius in response to which Judas had risen and refused to pay tribute. Josephus laid the charge of all subsequent zealotry and even the whole Jewish revolt of the 60s to the charge of Judas and his collaborator Saduk. He even called them a fourth philosophical school outside the three main sects (the Pharisees, Sadducees and the Essenes).4 What was at stake for them was that even acknowledging the sovereignty of a foreign ruler was contrary to the law of God. In NT times, the word λῃσταί (lestai) to describe these kind of zealots which translates to ‘bandit’ or ‘robber’. Interestingly, in Mark 15:27, the two ‘robbers’ crucified next to Christ Jesus also bear the title λῃστής (lestes). Barabbas is also called a λῃστής in John 18:40. Some manuscripts even call him ἀρχιληστής or chief bandit. As opposed to κλέφτης (kleptes), which indicates a thief who operates in stealth, λῃστής refers to an open dacoit or bandit who plunders people with harm in broad daylight. In our context this also meant with the explicit intention of political subversion. Mark similarly speaks about why Barabbas had been convicted. He “had made insurrection with him, who had committed murder in the insurrection.” (Mark 15:7) These bandits had become a menace to public order in the name of zeal for Israel.
In addition to these, there were also the Sicarii (a latinization of the Greek σικάριοι) whose name derives from the Latin sica meaning dagger. They were assassin zealots who would murder Rome sympathizers in broad daylight and blend into the crowd. One of their earliest targets was an ex-high priest, Jonathan son of Annas.5 A military tribune in Jerusalem confuses the apostle Paul for one of the Sicarii, “Art not thou that Egyptian, which before these days madest an uproar, and leddest out into the wilderness four thousand men that were murderers (τῶν σικαρίων)? According to Bruce, Josephus calls all kinds of zealots (even the ones related to Judas the Galilean and his followers) Sicarii because that term ‘did not have the honourable associations that ‘Zealot’—and probably even lestes—had.’6 Josephus really did not like these men for in his eyes he hurt the Jewish cause. He portrayed them as savage and mercenary even as they were holed up in Masada. But recent excavations indicate that they were scrupulously religious Jews contrary to the picture that Josephus has painted. This is exactly the kind of tension that characterizes the violent and ostensibly unlawful practices of the zealots that are intermingled with true piety towards God. This is also exemplified in the life of the apostle Paul.
Saul the Zealot
The apostle Paul’s zeal experienced a death and a resurrection. In his former life he was a Pharisee. So, he would not be characterized as a Zealot by Josephus. He was neither one of the Sicarii nor a lestes but a respectable member of the Sanhedrin. And yet he had Phinehas-like religious zeal expressed in his great persecution of Christians. Hurtado talks about the praises of Phinehan zeal in the Sirach, Ecclesiasticus and Philo. He goes on to apply this to the apostle Paul and postulates that in his pre-converted life, the main reason why he was zealous against Christians was because of their ‘inappropriate reverence for Jesus.’ If Jesus was not God, as he had supposed, then it was right to pursue and punish all those who worshipped him as God and not just any god but the covenant God of Israel, Yahweh. This went straight against the very first commandment in the decalogue. Hurtado thinks that in the apostle Paul’s mind the crucifixion of Jesus was a just punishment from God for his claims to divinity.7 “Cursed is any one who hangs on a tree” (Deut 21:23) Of course, when he became a Christian, he understood that indeed Jesus was cursed in his crucifixion but that it was for the sake of sinners. So, Saul’s rage against the Christians and against Christ was because of the height of their idolatry (in his mind). This is in line with the charges of blasphemy that are placed on Jesus throughout the Gospels.
The apostle Paul reflects on this zeal in various places throughout the NT. He was more exceedingly zealous of the traditions of his fathers (Gal 1:4). When addressing the mob gathered against him in Jerusalem, he confirms to them that he was a persecutor of ‘this way’ ie. the Christian way ‘being zealous towards God as ye all are this day’ (Acts 22:3-4). In other words, he reckons his own persecution of the church as the same kind of zeal that the Jews were exercising against him. In another place, he describes the zeal of the Jews for God as ‘not according to knowledge.’ (Romans 10:2). In another place, he describes his persecution of the church as the height of his zeal which he now counts worse than refuse for the sake of Christ (Phil 3:6-7). What is fascinating about the apostle Paul’s reflection on his former zeal as well as the present zeal of his fellow kinsmen is that he recognizes it as a legitimate earthly good, even though it resulted in the persecution and martyrdom of the saints of God. He does recognize its wrong-headedness and that it is of no value in currying favor with God. (Who can trick God?) Having become a Christian, he calls the church in Crete through Titus to be “zealous for good works” (Titus 2:14)
Righteous Zeal
The zeal of Sicarii is described by Josephus as their extreme unwillingness to acknowledge Caesar as lord even when tortured, taken captive or executed. Bruce helpfully points out:
Those of us who are prone to admire the early Christians for persisting in just such a refusal must readily concede the constancy of those patriotic Jews, who refused to utter a confession which, in their eyes, would have been disloyalty to the God of their fathers.8
Our Lord taught us that our righteousness must exceed that of the Pharisees (Matthew 5:20). Likewise, it may be said that our zeal must exceed that of the Sicarii. They were willing to die rather than call another king and lord besides Yahweh. Their bravery, misplaced as it was, has to be juxtaposed against the wickedness of the Jerusalem Jews who unashamedly confessed, “We have no king but Caesar.” (John 19:15) Christians must be willing to die for God, to offend anyone for the sake of God and to do whatsoever he may command. Even so, as Sandhu Sundar Singh has said, “It is easy to die for Christ. It is hard to live for Him. Dying takes only an hour or two, but to live for Christ means to die daily.” We must exceed in our zeal for God not only by being willing to die and to offend others for God, but also by by killing our sin daily and walking over the bellies of our lusts.
Conclusion
Zeal for the Lord is not a bad thing. Our Lord Himself exercised great and violent zeal against the moneychangers in the temple where his disciples connected his zeal with the Scripture that reads, “zeal for your house hath eaten me up.” (John 2:17, cf. Psalm 69:9) Even so, like every good thing, fallen man has bent zeal to ungodly ends. It is zeal for God that got Christ Jesus killed by the Pharisees. This has happened in the history of the church many times—the Hasmoneans, the Essenes, the lestai, the Sicarii and even the apostle Paul—all were led astray by their zeal. According to the apostle Paul, zeal needs knowledge to be sane.
We live in a world full of apostasy. We live in a world consumed by unthinking zeal. The nature of social media and our public discourse today precludes deliberate thought. Algorithms are built as instruments of instigation to get people straight from feeling to action bypassing any thought. But God calls us to zeal according to knowledge. To know the law of God, to meditate on it day and night, to strive to walk in obedience to it, not according to letter but according to the Spirit—these are the prerequisites for righteous zeal. The cautionary tales of fanatic zeal ought to humble us to ensure that nothing rouses our wrath apart from dishonor of God. And even there, the apostle James teaches us that “the wrath of man does not produce the righteousness of God” (James 1:20) So the call is to be slow to wrath and to put to death any bitterness and overflow of wickedness that rises in our hearts. Jovial forgiven hearts, free from bitterness, are the only kind that the Lord will use to display his zeal for his glory.
Everett Ferguson, Backgrounds of Early Christianity, 3rd ed. (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2003), 522.
Flavius Josephus, The Antiquities of the Jews, in Josephus: The Complete Works: Encounter the World and Traditions That Jesus Knew, trans. William Whiston (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 2003), 18.8.
F. F. Bruce, New Testament History (Garden City, NY: Galilee/Doubleday, 1980), 97–98.
Josephus, Antiquities, 18.9, 23.
Josephus, Antiquities, 20.164
Bruce, New Testament History, 99.
Larry W. Hurtado, Destroyer of the Gods: Early Christian Distinctiveness in the Roman World (Waco, TX: Baylor University Press, 2016), 17–18.
Bruce, New Testament History, 100.
Originally published on The Flying Scroll.



Leave a comment
Please log in to join the conversation — it's free. Don't have an account? Join here.